In “Broad Arrow,” Caroline Leakey presents a gripping narrative that blends elements of realism with the aesthetics of Victorian literature, serving as a profound critique of penal colonies in colonial Australia. Through the eyes of her protagonist, who navigates the brutal reality of life in a convict settlement, Leakey employs rich, descriptive prose and touches on themes of survival, morality, and societal injustice. The novel is steeped in historical context and draws on contemporary debates surrounding justice and punishment, offering readers a sobering reflection on colonial ideology and the human condition. Caroline Leakey, an influential figure in 19th-century literature, was deeply engaged with social reform movements, particularly those related to justice and women's rights. Her personal experiences and keen observations of the societal inequities of her time inspired her to shed light on the often-overlooked lives of convicts and their untold hardships. Leakey's background as an advocate for social reform and her exposure to the legal systems of her time infuse “Broad Arrow” with authenticity and urgency. For readers interested in historical fiction that combines lyrical prose with incisive social commentary, “Broad Arrow” is a compelling choice. It not only captivates with its vivid storytelling but also challenges the reader to reflect on the legacies of colonialism and the complexities of justice. This novel is crucial for those seeking a deeper understanding of Australia's colonial past and the systemic issues surrounding punishment and redemption.